what's new
93 TopicsAnnouncing Public Preview: New STIX Objects in Microsoft Sentinel
Security teams often struggle to understand the full context of an attack. In many cases, they rely solely on Indicators of Compromise (IoCs) without the broader insights provided by threat intelligence developed on Threat Actors, Attack Patterns, Identities - and the Relationships between each. This lack of context available to enrich their workflows limits their ability to connect the dots, prioritize threats effectively, and respond comprehensively to evolving attacks. To help customers build out a thorough, real-time understanding of threats, we are excited to announce the public preview of new Threat Intelligence (TI) object support in Microsoft Sentinel and in the Unified SOC Platform. In addition to Indicators of Compromise (IoCs), Microsoft Sentinel now supports Threat Actors, Attack Patterns, Identities, and Relationships. This enhancement empowers organizations to take their threat intelligence management to the next level. In this blog, we’ll highlight key scenarios for which your team would use STIX objects, as well as demos showing how to create objects and new relationships and how to use them to hunt threats across your organization Key Scenarios STIX objects are a critical tool for incident responders attempting to understand an attack and threat intelligence analysts seeking more information on critical threats. It is designed to improve interoperability and sharing of threat intelligence across different systems and organizations. Below, we’ve highlighted four ways Unified SOC Platform customers can begin using STIX objects to protect their organization. Ingesting Objects: You can now ingest these objects from various commercial feeds through several methods including STIX TAXII servers, API, files, or manual input. Curating Threat Intelligence: Curate and manage any of the supported Threat Intelligence objects. Creating Relationships: Establish connections between objects to enhance threat detection and response. For example: Connecting Threat Actor to Attack Pattern: The threat actor "APT29" uses the attack pattern "Phishing via Email" to gain initial access. Linking Indicator to Threat Actor: An indicator (malicious domain) is attributed to the threat actor "APT29". Associating Identity (Victim) with Attack Pattern: The organization "Example Corp" is targeted by the attack pattern "Phishing via Email". Hunt and Investigate Threats More Effectively: Match curated TI data against your logs in the unified SOC platform powered by Microsoft Sentinel. Use these insights to detect, investigate, and hunt threats more efficiently, keeping your organization secure. Get Started Today with the new Hunting Model The ability to ingest and manage these new Threat Intelligence objects is now available in public preview. To enable this data in your workspaces for hunting and detection, submit your request here and we will provide further details. Demo and screen shots Demo 1: Hunt and detect threats using STIX objects Scenario: Linking an IOC to a Threat Actor: An indicator (malicious domain) is attributed to the threat actor " Sangria tempest " via the new TI relationship builder. Please note that the Sangria tempest actor object and the IOC are already present in this demo. These objects can be added automatically or created manually. To create new relationship, sign into your Sentinel instance and go to Add new à TI relationship. In the New TI relationship builder, you can select existing TI objects and define how it's related to one or more other TI objects. After defining a TI object’s relationship, click on “Common” to provide metadata for this relationship, such as Description, Tags, and Confidence score: Another type of meta data a customer can add to a relationship is the Traffic Light Protocol (TLP). The TLP is a set of designations used to ensure that sensitive information is shared with the appropriate audience. It uses four colors to indicate different levels of sensitivity and the corresponding sharing permissions: TLP:RED: Information is highly sensitive and should not be shared outside of the specific group or meeting where it was originally disclosed. TLP:AMBER: Information can be shared with members of the organization, but not publicly. It is intended to be used within the organization to protect sensitive information. TLP:GREEN: Information can be shared with peers and partner organizations within the community, but not publicly. It is intended for a wider audience within the community. TLP:WHITE: Information can be shared freely and publicly without any restrictions. Once the relationship is created, your newly created relationship can be viewed from the “Relationships” tab. Now, retrieve information about relationships and indicators associated with the threat actor 'Sangria Tempest'. For Microsoft Sentinel customers leveraging the Azure portal experience, you can access this in Log Analytics. For customers who have migrated to the unified SecOps platform in the Defender portal, you can go find this under “Advanced Hunting”. The following KQL query provides you with all TI objects related to “Sangria Tempest.” You can use this query for any threat actor name. let THREAT_ACTOR_NAME = 'Sangria Tempest'; let ThreatIntelObjectsPlus = (ThreatIntelObjects | union (ThreatIntelIndicators | extend StixType = 'indicator') | extend tlId = tostring(Data.id) | extend StixTypes = StixType | extend Pattern = case(StixType == "indicator", Data.pattern, StixType == "attack-pattern", Data.name, "Unkown") | extend feedSource = base64_decode_tostring(tostring(split(Id, '---')[0])) | summarize arg_max(TimeGenerated, *) by Id | where IsDeleted == false); let ThreatActorsWithThatName = (ThreatIntelObjects | where StixType == 'threat-actor' | where Data.name == THREAT_ACTOR_NAME | extend tlId = tostring(Data.id) | extend ActorName = tostring(Data.name) | summarize arg_max(TimeGenerated, *) by Id | where IsDeleted == false); let AllRelationships = (ThreatIntelObjects | where StixType == 'relationship' | extend tlSourceRef = tostring(Data.source_ref) | extend tlTargetRef = tostring(Data.target_ref) | extend tlId = tostring(Data.id) | summarize arg_max(TimeGenerated, *) by Id | where IsDeleted == false); let SourceRelationships = (ThreatActorsWithThatName | join AllRelationships on $left.tlId == $right.tlSourceRef | join ThreatIntelObjectsPlus on $left.tlTargetRef == $right.tlId); let TargetRelationships = (ThreatActorsWithThatName | join AllRelationships on $left.tlId == $right.tlTargetRef | join ThreatIntelObjectsPlus on $left.tlSourceRef == $right.tlId); SourceRelationships | union TargetRelationships | project ActorName, StixTypes, ObservableValue, Pattern, Tags, feedSource You now have all the information your organization has available about Sangria Tempest, correlated to maximize your understanding of the threat actor and its associations to threat infrastructure and activity. Demo 2: Curate and attribute objects We have created new UX to streamline TI object creation, which includes the capability to attribute to other objects, so while you are creating a new IoC, you can also attribute that indicator to a Threat Actor, all from one place. To create a new TI object and attribute it to one or multiple threat actors, follow the steps below: Go to Add new a TI Object. In the Context menu, select any object type. Enter all the required information in the fields on the right-hand side for your selected indicator type. While creating a new TI object, you can do TI object curation. This includes defining the relationship. You can also quickly duplicate TI objects, making it easier for those who create multiple TI objects daily. Please note that we also introduced an “Add and duplicate” button to allow customers to create multiple TI objects with the same metadata to streamline a manual bulk process. Demo 3: New supported IoC types The attack pattern builder now supports the creation of four new indicator types. These enable customers to build more specific attack patterns that boost understanding of and organizational knowledge around threats. These new indicators include: X509 certificate X509 certificates are used to authenticate the identity of devices and servers, ensuring secure communication over the internet. They are crucial in preventing man-in-the-middle attacks and verifying the legitimacy of websites and services. For instance, if a certificate is suddenly replaced or a new, unknown certificate appears, it could indicate a compromised server or a malicious actor attempting to intercept communications. JA3 JA3 fingerprints are unique identifiers generated from the TLS/SSL handshake process. They help in identifying specific applications and tools used in network traffic, making it easier to detect malicious activities For example, if a network traffic analysis reveals a JA3 fingerprint matching that of the Cobalt Strike tool, it could indicate an ongoing cyber attack. JA3S JA3S fingerprints extend the capabilities of JA3 by also including server-specific characteristics in the fingerprinting process. This provides a more comprehensive view of the network traffic and helps in identifying both client and server-side threats For instance, if a server starts communicating with an unknown external IP address using a specific JA3S fingerprint, it could be a sign of a compromised server or data exfiltration attempt. User agent User Agents provide information about the client software making requests to a server, such as the browser or operating system. They are useful in identifying and profiling devices and applications accessing a network For example, if a User Agent string associated with a known malicious browser extension appears in network logs, it could indicate a compromised device. Conclusion: The ability to ingest, curate, and establish relationships between various threat intelligence objects such as Threat Actors, Attack Patterns, and Identities provides a powerful framework for incident responders and threat intelligence analysts. The use of STIX objects not only improves interoperability and sharing of threat intelligence but also empowers organizations to hunt and investigate threats more efficiently. As customers adopt these new capabilities, they will find themselves better equipped to understand the full context of an attack and build robust defenses against future threats. With the public preview of Threat Intelligence (TI) object support, organizations are encouraged to explore these new tools and integrate them into their security operations, taking the first step towards a more informed and proactive approach to cybersecurity.2.6KViews2likes1CommentIntroducing Threat Intelligence Ingestion Rules
Microsoft Sentinel just rolled out a powerful new public preview feature: Ingestion Rules. This feature lets you fine-tune your threat intelligence (TI) feeds before they are ingested to Microsoft Sentinel. You can now set custom conditions and actions on Indicators of Compromise (IoCs), Threat Actors, Attack Patterns, Identities, and their Relationships. Use cases include: Filter Out False Positives: Suppress IoCs from feeds known to generate frequent false positives, ensuring only relevant intel reaches your analysts. Extending IoC validity periods for feeds that need longer lifespans. Tagging TI objects to match your organization's terminology and workflows Get Started Today with Ingestion Rules To create new “Ingestion rule”, navigate to “Intel Management” and Click on “Ingestion rules” With the new Ingestion rules feature, you have the power to modify or remove indicators even before they are integrated into Sentinel. These rules allow you to act on indicators currently in the ingestion pipeline. > Click on “Ingestion rules” Note: It can take up to 15 minutes for the rule to take effect Use Case #1: Delete IOC’s with less confidence score while ingesting When ingesting IOC's from TAXII/Upload API/File Upload, indicators are imported continuously. With pre-ingestion rules, you can filter out indicators that do not meet a certain confidence threshold. Specifically, you can set a rule to drop all indicators in the pipeline with a confidence score of 0, ensuring that only reliable data makes it through. Use Case #2: Extending IOC’s The following rule can be created to automatically extend the expiration date for all indicators in the pipeline where the confidence score is greater than 75. This ensures that these high-value indicators remain active and usable for a longer duration, enhancing the overall effectiveness of threat detection and response. Use Case #3: Bulk Tagging Bulk tagging is an efficient way to manage and categorize large volumes of indicators based on their confidence scores. With pre-ingestion rules, you can set up a rule to tag all indicators in the pipeline where the confidence score is greater than 75. This automated tagging process helps in organizing indicators, making it easier to search, filter, and analyze them based on their tags. It streamlines the workflow and improves the overall management of indicators within Sentinel. Managing Ingestion rules In addition to the specific use cases mentioned, managing ingestion rules gives you control over the entire ingestion process. 1. Reorder Rules You can reorder rules to prioritize certain actions over others, ensuring that the most critical rules are applied first. This flexibility allows for a tailored approach to data ingestion, optimizing the system's performance and accuracy. 2. Create From Creating new ingestion rules from existing ones can save you a significant amount of time and offer the flexibility to incorporate additional logic or remove unnecessary elements. Effectively duplicating these rules ensures you can quickly adapt to new requirements, streamline operations, and maintain a high level of efficiency in managing your data ingestion process. 3. Delete Ingestion Rules Over time, certain rules may become obsolete or redundant as your organizational needs and security strategies evolve. It's important to note that each workspace is limited to a maximum of 25 ingestion rules. Having a clean and relevant set of rules ensures that your data ingestion process remains streamlined and efficient, minimizing unnecessary processing and potential conflicts. Deleting outdated or unnecessary rules allows for a more focused approach to threat detection and response. It reduces clutter, which can significantly enhance the performance. By regularly reviewing and purging obsolete rules, you maintain a high level of operational efficiency and ensure that only the most critical and up-to-date rules are in place. Conclusion By leveraging these pre-ingestion rules effectively, you can enhance the quality and reliability of the IOC’s ingested into Sentinel, leading to more accurate threat detection and an improved security posture for your organization.2.6KViews2likes2CommentsHelp Protect your Exchange Environment With Microsoft Sentinel
TL;DR; Sentinel + Exchange Servers or Exchange Online = better protected New Microsoft Sentinel security solution for Exchange Online and on premises servers : Microsoft Exchange Security! This content is very useful for any organization concerned about keeping the highest security posture as possible and be alerted in case of suspicious activities for those critical items.17KViews6likes12CommentsGo agentless with Microsoft Sentinel for SAP
What a title during Agentic AI times 😂 Dear community, Bringing SAP workloads under the protection of your SIEM solution is a primary concern for many customers out there. The window for defenders is small “Critical SAP vulnerabilities being weaponized in less than 72 hours of a patch release and new unprotected SAP applications provisioned in cloud (IaaS) environments being discovered and compromised in less than three hours.” (SAP SE + Onapsis, Apr 6 2024) Having a turn-key solution as much as possible leads to better adoption of SAP security. Agent-based solutions running in Docker containers, Kubernetes, or other self-hosted environemnts are not for everyone. Microsoft Sentinel for SAP’s latest new capability re-uses the SAP Cloud Connector to profit from already existing setups, established integration processes, and well-understood SAP components. Meet agentless ❌🤖 The new integration path leverages SAP Integration Suite to connect Microsoft Sentinel with your SAP systems. The Cloud integration capability of SAP Integration Suite speaks all relevant protocols, has connectivity into all the places where your SAP systems might live, is strategic for most SAP customers, and is fully SAP RISE compatible by design. Are you deployed on SAP Business Technology Platform yet? Simply upload our Sentinel for SAP integration package (see bottom box in below image) to your SAP Cloud Integration instance, configure it for your environment, and off you go. Best of all: The already existing SAP security content (detections, workbooks, and playbooks) in Microsoft Sentinel continues to function the same way as it does for the Docker-based collector agent variant. The integration marks your steppingstone to bring your SAP threat signals into the Unified Security Operations Platform – a combination of Defender XDR and Sentinel – that looks beyond SAP at your whole IT estate. Microsoft Sentinel solution for SAP applications is certified for SAP S/4HANA Cloud, Private Edition RISE with SAP, and SAP S/4HANA on-premises. So, you are all good to go😎 You are already dockerized or agentless? Then proceed to this post to learn more about what to do once the SAP logs arrived in Sentinel. Final Words During the private preview we saw drastically reduced deployment times for SAP customers being less familiar with Docker, Kubernetes and Linux administration. Cherry on the cake: the network challenges don’t have to be tackled again. The colleagues running your SAP Cloud Connector went through that process a long time ago. SAP Basis rocks 🤘 Get started from here. Find more details on our blog on the SAP Community and latest Microsoft Learn article. Cheers Martin809Views1like0CommentsGITHUB - AI Sentinel attack simulation
The recent support for Model Context Protocol (MCP) with Claude Desktop has opened the door for some really useful testing capability with Sentinel and emerging threats. I'm happy to share with the community a GitHub project that demonstrates the use of MCP against current exploits to generate simulated attack data that can be used with testing migrated ASIM alert rules. MCP allows for up-to-date exploits to be queried... ... and with AI prompting, simulated attack events can be created against our Sentinel test environments. Which results in a simulated attack based on the exploit being referenced. This is really useful for testing the migration of our Sentinel alert rules to ASIM! The full code and details about the project are available here: https://laurierhodes.info/node/175115Views1like1CommentIntroducing SOC Optimization Recommendations Based on Similar Organizations
One of the key challenges that security teams in modern SOCs regularly face is determining which new data sources to onboard and which detections to activate. This ongoing process takes time and requires constant evaluation of the organization’s assets and the value that the data brings to the SOC. "…determining which logs to ingest for better threat coverage is time-consuming and requires significant effort. I need to spend a long time identifying the appropriate logs..." Elie El Karkafi, Senior Solutions Architect, ampiO Solutions Today, we’re excited to announce the public preview of recommendations based on similar organizations - a first-of-its-kind capability for SOC optimizations. Recommendations based on similar organizations use peer-based insights to guide and accelerate your decision-making process. We believe that applying insights learned from the actions of organizations with similar profiles can provide great value. Recommendations based on similar organizations use advanced machine learning to suggest which data to ingest, based on organizations with similar ingestion patterns. The recommendations also highlight the security value you can gain by adding the data. They list out-of-the-box rules that are provided by Microsoft research, which you can activate to enhance your coverage. Use the new recommendations to swiftly pinpoint the next recommended data source for ingestion and determine the appropriate detections to apply. This can significantly reduce the time and costs typically associated with research or consulting external experts to gain the insights you need. Recommendations based on similar organizations are now available in the SOC optimization page, in both the Azure portal and the unified security operations platform: - unified security operations platform Use cases Let’s take a tour of the unified security operations platform, stepping into the shoes of a small tech company that benefited from recommendations based on similar organizations during its private preview phase. In the following image, the new recommendation identifies that the AADNonInteractiveUserSignInLogs table is used by organizations similar to theirs: Selecting View details button on the recommendation card allowed them to explore how other organizations use the recommended table. This includes insights into the percentage of organizations using the table for detection and investigation purposes. By selecting See details hyperlink, the SOC engineer was able to explore how coverage could be improved with respect to the MITRE ATT&CK framework, using Microsoft’s out-of-the box rules: By selecting Go to Content hub, the SOC engineer was able to view all the essential data connectors needed to start ingesting the recommended tables. This page also includes a detailed list of out of the box, recommended analytics rules, which can provide immediate value and enhanced protection for your environment: Finally, by following the recommendation, which uses the security practices of similar organizations as a benchmark, the tech company quickly ingested the AADNonInteractiveUserSignInLogs table and activated several recommended analytics rules. Overall, this resulted in improved security coverage, corresponding to the company's specific characteristics and needs. Feedback from private preview: “I think this is a great addition. Like being able to identify tables not being used, it is useful to understand what tables other organizations are utilizing which could reveal things that so far haven't been considered or missed...” Chris Hoard, infinigate.cloud "In my view, those free recommendations are always welcomed and we can justify cost saving and empowering SOC analysts (that we know are more and more difficult to find)." Cyrus Irandoust, IBM “These recommendations will help us to take a look at the left out stuffs” Emmanuel Karunya, KPMG “Nice overview and insights! Love the interface too - nice and easy overview!” Michael Morten Sonne, Microsoft MVP Q&A: Q1: Why don’t I see these recommendations? A: Not all workspaces are eligible for recommendations based on similar organizations. Workspaces only receive these recommendations if the machine learning model identifies significant similarities between your organization and others, and discovers tables that they have but you don’t. If no such similarities are identified, no extra recommendations are provided. You’re more likely to see these recommendations if your SOC is still in its onboarding process, rather than a more mature SOC. Q2: What makes an organization similar to mine? A: Similarity is determined based on ingestion trends, as well as your organization's industry and vertical, when available in our databases. Q3: Is any of my PII being used to make recommendations to other customers? A: No. The recommendations are generated using machine learning models that rely solely on Organizational Identifiable Information (OII) and system metadata. Customer log content is never accessed or analyzed, and no customer data, content, or End User Identifiable Information (EUII) is exposed during the analysis process. Microsoft prioritizes customer privacy and ensures that all processes comply with the highest standards of data protection. Looking forward Microsoft continues to use artificial intelligence and machine learning to help our customers defend against evolving threats and provide enhanced protection against cyberattacks. This ongoing innovation is a key part of SOC optimization’s commitment to help you maximize your value from your SIEM & XDR. Learn More: SOC optimization documentation: SOC optimization overview ; Recommendation's logic Short overview and demo: SOC optimization Ninja show In depth webinar: Manage your data, costs and protections with SOC optimization SOC optimization API: Introducing SOC Optimization API | Microsoft Community Hub2.7KViews2likes1CommentWhat's New: View Microsoft Sentinel Workbooks Directly from Unified SOC Operations Platform
*This blog was posted on behalf of the original author, Aman Kaur. Thank you Aman for preparing this content for the community.* Key Benefits Unified Viewing Experience: Microsoft Sentinel workbook templates and saved workbooks can now be accessed directly within the Defender XDR portal. This eliminates the need to switch between different portals, providing a seamless experience. Increased Efficiency and Time Saving: The ability to view workbooks within the Defender XDR portal cuts down on the time spent navigating between portals, leading to faster access to critical information. Improved User Experience: This integration simplifies the process of referencing important data and insights, making it easier for security professionals to monitor security events, analyze trends, and review historical data. Important Note While viewing capabilities have been integrated into the Defender XDR portal, editing or creating workbooks will still require you to navigate to the Azure portal. This ensures that you have access to the full suite of editing tools and functionalities available in Azure. How to Get Started Getting started with viewing Microsoft Sentinel workbooks in the Defender XDR portal is simple: Access the Microsoft Defender XDR Portal: Log in to the Microsoft Defender XDR portal using your credentials. Navigate to Microsoft Sentinel > Threat Management > Workbooks : Select any workbook. View Workbooks: Access and view the templates and saved workbooks directly within the portal. Moving Forward with Sentinel Workbooks in Defender XDR Portal With the ability to view Microsoft Sentinel workbooks directly within the Microsoft Defender XDR portal, organizations can significantly enhance their security operations. This feature empowers security teams with the tools they need to efficiently monitor, investigate, and respond to threats—all from a single interface. By bringing together a unified viewing experience across incidents, alerts, users, devices, and files, this enhancement streamlines threat hunting, investigation, and response workflows. This ultimately helps organizations stay ahead of evolving threats and ensures they have the necessary context to protect their environment effectively. Get started with workbooks in the unified portal today!1.3KViews3likes0CommentsWhat’s new: Run playbooks on entities on-demand
SOC analysts can take action on a selected entity while investigating an incident or hunting entities; SOC engineers can encapsulate automated actions that run on a specific entity, saving time and making SOC more efficient and productive.9.8KViews1like4CommentsWhat's New: Global Search in Unified Security Operations platform includes Sentinel user and devices
We are thrilled to announce a significant enhancement to our Unified Security Operations (SecOps) platform. The Global Search feature in the Defender XDR portal now supports searching for Microsoft Sentinel users and devices, providing a more comprehensive and unified search experience for the customers using Microsoft’s Unified Security Operations platform. This powerful feature allows you to search for devices, users, and other information by typing full or partial search terms. With this update, you can now search for Microsoft Sentinel entities directly within the Unified security operations platform, streamlining your workflow and improving efficiency. Key Benefits Unified Search Results: Microsoft Sentinel devices and users are now merged with Microsoft Defender XDR portal entities, providing a single, unified search result. This eliminates the need to switch between different tools. Increased efficiency and Time saving - The ability to search across Sentinel incidents and other data in the Defender portal cuts down investigation time, leading to faster resolution of security incidents. Comprehensive Identifier Support: The search feature supports various identifiers, ensuring that devices and users from Microsoft Sentinel and Defender with matching identifiers are merged into a single result. This includes identifiers such as HostName, NTDomain, DnsDomain, and NetBiosName. Improved User Experience: The integration simplifies the search experience, making it easier for security professionals to find the information they need quickly and efficiently. This enhancement is part of our ongoing effort to consolidate Microsoft Sentinel entities within the comprehensive XDR+SIEM platform. How to Get Started Getting started with the Global Search feature is simple: Access the Microsoft Defender XDR Portal: Log in to the Microsoft Defender XDR portal using your credentials. Navigate to Global Search: Locate the Global Search bar at the top of the portal. Enter Search Terms: Type in the full or partial search terms for the device or user you are looking for. The search will now include Sentinel entities along with Defender entities. Review Unified Results: The search results will display a unified view of Microsoft Sentinel and Defender entities, allowing you to quickly find the information you need. Use-Cases & Scenarios Incident Investigation: An analyst can use Global Search to quickly find all affected devices related to an incident. This allows for a faster and more efficient investigation. This makes it easier to investigate the scope of the issue and prioritize the appropriate response. Threat Hunting: Threat hunters can use Global Search to locate suspicious user activity or specific files that have been flagged as malicious, correlating these findings with other related alerts in the system. Device Tracking: Security teams can use Global Search to track a compromised device, checking for alerts, users associated with the device, and any incidents that might involve it. Supported Sentinel Host Identifiers Sentinel devices with the following strong identifiers can be searched and merged with Defender devices with matching identifiers: HostName+NTDomain HostName+DnsDomain NetBiosName+NTDomain NetBiosName+DnsDomain Supported Account Identifiers Sentinel accounts with the following strong identifiers can be merged with Defender user with matching identifiers: Name+UPNSuffix AADUserId Sid Moving Forward with Global Search With Global Search for Sentinel entities now available in the Microsoft Defender XDR portal, organizations can significantly enhance their security operations. This feature empowers security teams with the tools they need to efficiently search, investigate, and respond to threats—all from a single interface. By bringing together a unified search across incidents, alerts, users, devices, and files, the Global Search feature streamlines threat hunting, investigation, and response workflows. This ultimately helps organizations stay ahead of evolving threats and ensures they have the necessary context to protect their environment effectively. For more detailed information and documentation on how to use Global Search, visit the official Microsoft 365 Defender portal documentation2.4KViews0likes1Comment